If you’re an established blogger, seeing your Pinterest traffic suddenly decline can be discouraging. One day you’re getting thousands of visitors, and the next you’re wondering what happened. Today I will cover what to do when your Pinterest traffic drops.
The good news is that a drop in Pinterest traffic doesn’t always mean you’ve done something wrong. Pinterest changes, user interests evolve, and even the best-performing content can slow down over time.
If you’ve been consistently creating quality content, publishing new blog posts, and pinning regularly, here are five things you should check before you panic.
Important: This advice is intended for established bloggers who have been consistently using Pinterest. If your blog is less than six months old or you’ve taken a long break from Pinterest, traffic fluctuations are expected and these tips may not apply.
Check out my post on How To Get Massive Traffic To Your Blog here. You may also enjoy my post on The Top 20 Pinterest-Friendly Blog Niches here.
What to Do When Your Pinterest Traffic Drops
1. Check Whether Pinterest Has Flagged Your Account or URL for Spam
One of the first things to investigate is whether Pinterest has mistakenly flagged your account or one of your URLs as spam.
Pinterest defines spam as misleading or deceptive content. For example, if a pin promises a chocolate cake recipe but sends users to an Etsy shop selling printable calendars, Pinterest considers that misleading.
However, sometimes legitimate bloggers get caught in spam filters because:
- A pin has been stolen.
- Someone copied your image and linked it to another website.
- Pinterest incorrectly flags one of your URLs.
How to Check
If you suspect a problem:
- Create a new pin in Pinterest.
- Upload an image.
- Paste the URL you’re testing.
- If Pinterest immediately displays a red warning stating the link may lead to spam, you’ve likely found the issue.
If that happens:
- Contact Pinterest Support.
- Explain that your content follows their guidelines.
- Ask them to review and unblock the URL.
Watch for Stolen Pins
Successful pins are often copied by other users.
If someone screenshots your pin and links it to their own website, report the stolen pin directly to Pinterest.
One simple habit that helps prove ownership is placing your website URL at the bottom of every Pinterest image. While this won’t prevent theft, it makes it much easier to demonstrate that the content belongs to you.
Unfortunately there is no specific way to check to see if you have stolen pins. The way I have always discovered a stolen pin is that it appears in my Pinterest feed. If this happens to you, report it.
2. Use Google Analytics to Find Which Blog Posts Lost Traffic
Instead of looking only at your overall traffic, dig deeper.
Open Google Analytics and review your individual blog posts (URLs).
Ask yourself:
- Which posts experienced the largest decline?
- Was the drop sudden or gradual?
- Are multiple posts affected or just one?
If a single URL lost most of its Pinterest traffic, test that URL in Pinterest as described above.
Sometimes the issue isn’t your entire account—it’s just one high-performing post that has been mistakenly flagged.
3. Continue Creating New Content
Pinterest exists to inspire people with fresh ideas.
Even evergreen content eventually slows down.
Think about trends like Stanley Cups. A product can become incredibly popular for a season, then gradually lose momentum as people’s interests change.
The same thing happens with blog posts.
Some pins continue performing for years. Others peak quickly and eventually fade.
The solution is simple:
Keep publishing new content.
Every new blog post gives Pinterest another opportunity to:
- Show your content to new users
- Rank for new keywords
- Generate additional traffic
Rather than relying on a handful of viral posts, build a large library of helpful content that continues growing over time.
4. Create New Pinterest Boards
This is a strategy that isn’t discussed very often.
Approximately every six months, consider creating a brand-new Pinterest board centered around fresh keywords in your niche.
New boards can:
- Refresh your Pinterest account
- Target additional search terms
- Create new opportunities for your pins to be discovered
Once the board is created, begin adding your new content as well as your most relevant existing pins.
Refreshing your account periodically helps signal continued activity to Pinterest while keeping your content organized around current topics.
5. Diversify Your Traffic Sources
This may be the most important tip of all.
Pinterest is an incredible source of blog traffic—but it should never be your only source.
Algorithms change.
User interests change.
Platforms change.
The more places people can discover your content, the more stable your business becomes.
Consider expanding into platforms such as:
- YouTube
- TikTok
- Email marketing
- Google Search (SEO)
Diversifying your traffic means you’re not depending on one platform to determine your income.
Remember: Traffic Comes in Seasons
If you’ve been blogging for any length of time, you’ve probably experienced what many creators call the Pinterest roller coaster.
Traffic rises.
Traffic falls.
Algorithms update.
Popular topics lose momentum.
This doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve failed.
Sometimes it’s simply a sign that it’s time to refresh your strategy and continue creating valuable content.
A Little Encouragement for Bloggers
One lesson I’ve learned is that challenges often force us to improve.
Sometimes difficult seasons reveal opportunities to make better content, learn new skills, or reach audiences in different ways.
One Bible passage that has encouraged me is James 1:2–4: 2 “Count it all joy, my brothers, when you meet trials of various kinds, 3 for you know that the testing of your faith produces steadfastness. 4 And let steadfastness have its full effect, that you may be perfect and complete, lacking in nothing.”
Hang in There and Stay Faithful! You will find success if you Don’t Quit!
Recent Comments